Do we have to talk about every vegetarian/vegan issue in the news?

I am torn about even writing this post. What has prompted it is something I’d prefer not get any attention. And yet, what has happened is something that I have spoken against publicly for years now.  

(See my blog “Creating a Movement” http://appetiteforjustice.blogspot.com/2010/05/creating-movement.html) 

It is about Sheriff Joe Arpaio. Now, I am not writing this as a diatribe against him and his racist and lethal policies. Being a Chicana, these hit close to home for me and, frankly, I admit I am annoyed that his name even graces my blog yet again. Instead, this is about asking my fellow vegan advocates to not use his name as anything but something aligned with disgust. 

Sheriff Joe Arpaio of Maricopa County, Arizona, instituted a policy that all of the inmates in his prison only receive vegetarian meals. When the news came in, I immediately worried that those who promote vegetarianism would talk about it. 

And unfortunately, I was correct.

Instead of allowing the media to promote this issue (which is happening just fine without our help), veg organizations and publications have chosen to do so. 

Are we so desperate in our desire to promote vegetarianism that we need to stoop so low as to promote Sheriff Joe?

 Because I fear sounding like a broken record, I have pasted below some of what I wrote on the issue regarding Arpaio's participation in the Prop 204 campaign:

[I]t certainly doesn’t help the plight of the animals when large animal groups use racists to further their campaigns. It is no wonder that environmental justice activists questioned the goals of animal advocates when animal groups engaged the assistance of Arizona's Sheriff Joe Arpaio, well known for targeting people of color. Anyone who claims to be compassionate should have known about his notorious treatment of human animals, which should have made him someone to stay away from.  

Many white advocates who actively fight for animal rights understand they are coming from a place of power—after all, animals really have no rights—but they seem ignorant regarding that place of power when it comes to race, gender, class, and sexual orientation.

Animal groups have a responsibility to be the frontrunners for justice and compassion, and our case is stronger without the likes of Sheriff Joe.

Blogs on similar issues:

Been down this road before: http://appetiteforjustice.blogspot.com/2011/02/been-down-this-road-before.html

Chipping Away Injustices: http://appetiteforjustice.blogspot.com/2012/09/chipping-away-at-injustices.html

 

Blackfish (The Importance of October 24th)

Seeing the movie Blackfish reminded me of a talk from my new favorite author Chimamanda Ngozi Adichie, “The Danger of a Single Story.” I really hope people will listen to her talk and her wisdom, her power. She discusses the problems that arise when we just tell one part of a story. 

Blackfish works to tell a whole story about a killer whale (also known as an orca) at SeaWorld Orlando and, to the best of the documentary’s ability, uses the voices and pain of orcas captured for captivity.

I have known for decades how animals end up in marine “parks,” zoos, and aquariums (or, as Ric O’Barry calls them, abusement “parks”), and yet most people only know about these animals’ lives in the context of a visit to one of these places. No knowledge of how they got there and what they go through. Only the story of their visit.

I was one of those people. 

In 1988, SeaWorld San Antonio opened. Now keep in mind, I was a bit naïve. As someone who was bullied in middle school and whose life was full of financial struggles, I still consider myself naïve about certain things. I was more than just naïve; I was in denial. I was already an ethical vegan and a fairly new animal rights activist.

SeaWorld sponsored a contest where high school students in San Antonio would write an essay and could win a college scholarship. I had not planned on going to college until my animal rights “parents” encouraged me to. So I was a bit behind on any planning.

So I decided to apply for this scholarship. During the contest, you got a free pass to SeaWorld.

For me, this was incredible, as I love the ocean but lived so far away, and wanted to be a marine biologist. I only saw one of the orca shows, as I spent most of my time watching the sharks (one of my favorite animals). I’ll fast forward a bit to why I didn’t get the scholarship: I wrote in the essay about how I felt whole by becoming an animal rights activist and, well, I believe I even talked about wanting to set all of the animals at SeaWorld free.

Umm…yeah….maybe not naïve or in denial, maybe just stupid….or honest.

The folks in the animal rights group were patient with me and knew that I saw the truth about how animals were treated in every other industry, and I imagine they knew I would come to my senses.

Over the years, we held protests at the San Antonio SeaWorld and displayed signs with a message that seems to be standing the test of time: “Thanks but no tanks.”

And what is more incredible is the reality that you have any sea creatures at all in San Antonio. It is land locked. But all marine “parks,” near the ocean or not, have these animals living in small areas with small tanks. It just seems incomprehensible to me. Truly. Who came up with this idea? How could anyone think it would be morally acceptable? Oh, wait….profit. They are preying on the hearts of people who do sincerely care about animals – people who get blinded by a story that starts in the middle and don’t hear the beginning or the end. They see only a snapshot.

It is not that I can’t understand what people think when they go to places like zoos and SeaWorld – they believe they are getting to know more about animals and that these animals are treated well. Of course, that is not the case; they are getting to know how animals behave in captivity, how they behave when they have been taken away from their families, how they behave when their natural habits are deprived. But even if that were not the case, would it make it right? Of course not.

That is why I am so glad that a book like Bleating Hearts (full review later) is coming out this fall. It re-stirred the passion in my heart to fight for these animals. I learned things I didn’t know. Things which burn in my heart and make me wonder why I have not dedicated my life to getting them out of these tanks.* That the reality is just too awful to believe.

And of course there is Blackfish, which is getting the attention and critical acclaim it deserves.

It is a painful movie to watch, but so necessary. Much of the pain stems from the reality of how the captivity industry has destroyed and continues to destroy families. The pain of the mother crying and searching for her baby when SeaWorld takes her away. Unbearable, truly unbearable. There is a lot of crying in the movie – both on the screen and in the audience. And rightly so. I know that those images will probably haunt me for the rest of my life (no different than the beak trimming of chicks for the egg industry).

And of course the film itself is about a larger issue than just this one orca. Lolita, captured in 1970 from the wild, is in the Seaquarium in Miami, where she lives alone as she is the only remaining orca. And here she remembers the unique language used only by her family who swims freely in the Puget Sound, a pod she cries out for. She calls out by herself. Alone.

These are the types of things that I can’t think of for too long for fear of going crazy. The type of psychological pain that we put them through on top of the physical pain is just too much to bear.

As an animal rights activist, I feel that way about all of the issues we work on, but now is our time. With countries like Bolivia, Costa Rica, India, Peru, and others banning animal captivity in zoos, circuses, and/or marine “parks,” now is the time for us to work to end these industries.

I know I will encourage my family in San Antonio to watch Blackfish and hope that my niece and nephew have the opportunity to see for themselves what SeaWorld is all about.

We must make sure that we do not allow animals to be torn from their families and denied everything that is natural to them to end in a tank while we just watch. We must make sure that their story does not end here.

Please join me in making sure that everyone sees Blackfish. With CNN running it on October 24, there should be few excuses to miss it.

Update: Blackfish is now streaming on Netflix!

*Of course, Food Empowerment Project continues to do our good work for farmed animals, for workers, and for justice, but I will do what I can to join others who are pushing this industry to its knees.

Why is it okay for kids to care (and not adults)?

Food Empowerment Project works to fight a variety of injustices, including the deaths of animals killed for food, farm workers who suffer and even sometimes die in the fields for produce, and the worst forms of child labor that take place in the chocolate industry.

And up until recently, my full-time job was working to stop electronic waste from being dumped overseas in developing countries and the social injustices in the solar industry.

Many times I am asked how I cope with all of this suffering that I surround myself with. My response is that working to stop these injustices gives me strength.

Over the past several weeks, I have come to realize something else that I recognize must help me, but I don’t know that I have ever given it credit. And I know many of you will find fault in this – so I apologize for my weakness in advance.

I have this uncanny ability to watch Netflix in the background while I work; in fact, many of my blogs are written this way.

My weakness? Cartoons and kids movies.* Yup.  Although many cause my heart to ache (Secret of Nimh, Fox and the Hound, Bambi, Dumbo, etc.), I tend to watch kids’ movies and cartoons that don’t. Because, well, their drama is not drama when you aren’t a teen or a tween.

While watching these shows, I have started to recognize a unifying theme: those who abuse and kill animals are vilified (no shock here, as many who torture animals say animal rights activists were brainwashed by Disney), but also, the characters who love animals tend to be the heroes or the “smart” kids.

Again, I am not revealing anything shocking here, as we know that in movies including 101 Dalmatians, Beauty and the Beast, and Rescues Down Under, those who kill hunt or want to harm animals are mocked for, well, not being as smart as the average bear.

But I am talking more about the live-action kids’ movies where the kids are organizing animal rights protests against companies that test on animals, students oppose dissection, and those young characters who are vegetarians or even vegans.

They are respected. They are seen as the smart kids.

And yet, why does that change as we get older? Why do adults get an eye roll if we care about animals so much that we go vegan, and yet a child who does this because they care about animals is actually seen as cute and/or smart for their age?

Why are children who work to stop slavery looked upon as saints, but organizations who work to stop the slavery are seen as somehow political?

We all know that as children, we are raised to care about animals and slowly that changes, but why does public perception change?

Why are there shows about kids who care about animals, but such caring in adults is portrayed as crazy or radical?

The movie Hoot (based on a book) is about kids wanting to protect land from development to save the burrowing owl. The kids bond by wanting to protect these endangered animals. And yet organizations that want to do this same work are criticized as being anti-development.

I hesitate to say it, but I would imagine that we stop being cute and start becoming a concern when we could impact, well, capitalism.

Clearly, I am not saying that shows never portray vegans as respectable, but I am amazed by how many kids’ shows really depict caring about animals as a bonus to a child’s character.

It is refreshing. Overall, it gives me hope that a generation of young people will be bolstered enough by their compassion for animals that will it stay with them for a lifetime.

Because these are the people who will save countless lives in their lifetime.

Whatever it is, I hope movies and books continue to come out featuring characters who care about protecting animals and the planet, and in which those who fight for justice are the smart, compassionate, and indeed likeable characters.

Just like we are when we grow up!

*I know that many of these movies are actually based on books, but some of these books came out when, well, it was just easier to watch the movie.